A Partial Engagement –the story of partial collar errors


This article was published in the Australasian Coin and Banknote Magazine, March 2017 issue and was written by the Australian Coin Collecting Blog.Subscribe here to CAB magazine.

What is a Partial Collar Error?
The Partial Collar Error is an interesting type of coin error that gets its name as the coin only partially engages with the collar die when it is struck giving the rim a stepped appearance around some or all of the circumference of the coin.

The error occurs as the coin blank is fed into the press by the feeder fingers and doesn’t neatly locate in the collar die. As the coin is struck some of the planchet is driven into the collar die. The collar die constrains flow of the metal radially, resulting in the rim of the coin having a smaller diameter where it is held by the collar die and a larger diameter where it is not. Examining the edge of the struck coin to see how the collar held the coin allows the error to be classified by the collector into one of two types of partial collar error, straight or tilted.

Figure 1 shows a straight partial collar error, while Figure 2 shows a tilted partial collar error. Figure 3 shows a partial collar error on a non-reeded edge coin.
From the images below it should be clear that in the case of a straight partial collar the coin engages with the collar such that the double edge is parallel to the faces of the coin. The step in the edge around the full circumference of the coin gives the coin more than a passing resemblance to the wheel of a train carriage or locomotive, leading to the colloquial name “railroad rim error” for the straight partial collar. In the case of the tilted partial collar the double edge is not parallel to the faces of the coin giving rise to a tilted appearance.

Figure 1 (left) - Straight Partial Collar Edge – Great Britain 1966 Sixpence Figure 2 (middle) - Tilted Partial Collar Edge – Australia 2005 Dollar Figure 3 (right)- Straight Partial Collar Edge – Australia 1974 2c

Figure 1 (left) – Straight Partial Collar Edge – Great Britain 1966 Sixpence
Figure 2 (middle) – Tilted Partial Collar Edge – Australia 2005 Dollar
Figure 3 (right)- Straight Partial Collar Edge – Australia 1974 2c

Partial collar errors don’t usually look too spectacular when viewing the obverse or reverse face of the coin. Typically it’s when taking a closer look at the edge that it becomes obvious where the problem has occurred. In the case of a straight partial collar error the side of the coin that correctly engages with the collar die should look for all intents and purposes, like a correctly struck coin. However, with the opposing side effectively struck out of collar the diameter should be greater than standard. It’s on this side of the coin that you may see metal flow and fishtailing due to unconstrained radial metal flow. See Figure 4.

Figure 4- Australia 1974 2c Partial Collar – Obverse Fishtailing Detail

Figure 4- Australia 1974 2c Partial Collar – Obverse Fishtailing Detail


Why Do Partial Collar Errors Occur?
There are two commonly accepted reasons for partial collar errors. The first has to do with the manufacture of the coin blanks themselves, the second a failure in the operation of the coin press machinery.

Improperly Manufactured Coin Blanks
What is one reason that a coin blank wouldn’t sit neatly in the collar for striking? The answer is quite obvious and is answered in Figure 5, a letter from the Royal Mint in London dated 1968. This letter is a response to Mr. C. McMillan who had mailed a straight partial collar 1966 sixpence error (Figure 1) to the Royal Mint asking for an explanation as to the origins of the coin. J.C. Hill, an employee of the Royal Mint, in reply to Mr. McMillan says:

“Your coin escaped this process and was therefore too large to fit properly into the collar which cuts the milled edge when the coin is struck.”

How can a coin blank possibly be too large? Simply because it has mistakenly missed the edge rimming process which raises the edge of the blank to reduce wear on the coin, reduces required striking pressure and according to J.C. Hill, allows coins to be stacked. An obvious side effect of the edge rimming process is that it reduces the diameter of the coin blank. The forfeiture of the edge rimming process leaves the coin blank too wide to fall neatly into the collar and only the part of the blank that is held by the collar receives the edge milling.

Machinery Failure
Herbert (2002) suggests a second reason for the partial collar error. Failure in some aspect of the coin press itself. He says:

“The collar may not rise and fall properly with the striking process, the support springs may break, or the collar may jam.”

It’s easy to see how in any of these cases that the collar die would only be raised partially around the rim of the coin even for a perfectly manufactured coin blank. In Mr. Herbert’s case of broken collar die support springs it is not inconceivable that just one spring could break resulting in a tilted collar die which could easily explain tilted partial collar errors.

How Common is this Type of Coin Error?
Partial collar errors are among the more common errors available to collectors. They are certainly the most common type of error coin that arise from planchet location problems during striking. Ramstrikes, broadstrikes and off-center strikes are other errors that result from planchet location issues but each is far scarcer than the partial collar.
Most of these more grossly deformed types of errors usually get picked up either by the Mint or by security companies when they are rejected at the coin rolling machines. Sometimes smaller less deformed partial collar errors find their way into circulation. Partial collar errors are more commonly found on the smaller denominations and they are easily overlooked and sometimes circulate for a while before being put aside by a collector.

Figure 5 -Royal Mint Letter

Figure 5 -Royal Mint Letter


A Recent Find
An Australasian Coin and Banknote reader was over the moon when he recently opened a Royal Australian Mint roll of freshly minted 2016 50th Anniversary of Decimal Currency Changeover 20 cent coins and found a partial collar error staring back at him. Glaringly obvious as can be seen in the photos (Figure 6) part of this coin didn’t engage at all with the collar die and there is a significant area with no milling around the edge. Our reader was quick to don his white gloves and carefully photograph the coin before putting it away in a coin holder. This is the first 2016 partial collar error the authors have seen and having come directly from a mint roll is retained in desirable uncirculated condition.
Figure 6 -2016 20c Partial Collar in RAM Roll (image supplied by Tyron Pigors)

Figure 6 -2016 20c Partial Collar in RAM Roll (image supplied by Tyron Pigors)


References
1. Richard Giedroyc, 2006. The Everything Coin Collecting Book: All You Need to Start Your Collection And Trade for Profit (Everything®). Adams Media.
2. Alan Herbert, 2002. The Official Price Guide to Mint Errors, 6th Edition. House of Collectibles.
3. Hill, J.C. (Royal Mint, London) to Mr.C. McMillan 5 February 1968 from collection of K. Harris.
4. Ian McConnelly, 2015. Renniks Australian Pre-Decimal & Decimal Coin Errors, 1st Edition. Renniks.
5. Australian Off Centre Strikes and Off Centre Dies. 2016. Australian Off Centre Strikes and Off Centre Dies. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.thesandpit.net/index.php?option=offcentre_strike. [Accessed 29 December 2016].


Posted in Error Coins

Site Search

Sponsors

Upcoming Coin Collecting Events:

Australian Numismatic Calendar

Current Coin Values, Bullion Prices and Exchange Rates

AUD $7.93
Australian 1966 Round 50c
AUD $398.58
Gold Sovereign
AUD $498.96
Australian $200 Gold Coin
AUD $23.22
Silver Price (per Oz)
AUD $1,693.04
Gold Price (per Oz)
USD $0.7477
Australian Dollar

 
These values are updated hourly using New York market prices. Coin values are purely the value of the gold or silver they contain and do not account for any numismatic value.
Prices Last Updated: 18:04 28 Apr 2017